What Questions Should I Ask a Pet Sitter? (Interview Checklist)

TL;DR: Quick Answer for Pet Parents:

To find a reliable pet sitter, ask about their professional certifications (NAPPS/PSI), pet first aid training, and emergency protocols. Ensure they can manage your pet’s specific routine, including medication and exercise. Use a detailed pet sitter interview checklist to verify their experience with your pet’s breed and temperament.

At Wellness Pet, we know your dog or cat isn’t just a pet—they are the heart of your home. Choosing someone to care for them while you’re away is a big decision, right up there with choosing the nutrient dense fuel you put in their bowl every morning.

Whether you’re planning a snowy mountain getaway or just need a hand during a busy work week, finding a sitter who prioritizes your pet’s holistic wellbeing is the key to total peace of mind. We’ve put together a Wellness-approved guide and checklist to help you find a professional who loves your pet almost as much as you do.

Why Choose a Professional Pet Sitter?

It’s always tempting to ask the teenager next door to pop in, but a professional pet sitter treats pet care as a dedicated career, not a side hustle. Professionals often hold certifications from the National Association of Professional Pet Sitters (NAPPS) or Pet Sitters International (PSI), ensuring they have the expertise to handle everything from a sudden rainstorm during a walk to a complex feeding schedule.

The Wellness benefits of a pro include:

• Health Savvy: They can recognize early signs of digestive upset or lethargy.
• Safety First: They’re usually trained in pet first aid and emergency response.
• Reliability: You get a business-first commitment to your pet’s routine.
• Breed Expertise: They understand that a high-energy Husky has very different needs than a soulful, senior Pug.

Your Pet Sitter Interview Checklist

Use these questions to ensure your candidate is a perfect match for your pet’s unique personality and health needs.

“Are you certified, insured, and bonded?”

Professionalism starts with protection. Being insured and bonded protects you, your pet, and the sitter if an accident happens or something goes sideways at home. It’s the baseline for a trustworthy partnership.

“How much experience do you have with my pet’s specific breed?”

Every breed has its own vibe. Ensure your sitter understands the specific exercise requirements, social needs, and even the common health sensitivities of your pet’s breed. A one size fits all approach doesn’t work for nutrition, and it doesn’t work for pet sitting either!

“What does a ‘day in the life’ look like during your visits?”

You want to know exactly how your pet’s time will be spent. A high-quality visit should always include:

• Fresh Water & Mindful Feeding: Serving up their favorite Wellness Protein Bowls or Wellness CORE+, CORE or Complete Health dry dog food recipe exactly on schedule.
• Physical & Mental Play: A good game of fetch or a “sniff-ari” walk to keep their tail wagging.
• The ‘Business’ Report: Waste cleanup and monitoring for any changes in habits.
• Photo Updates: Because we know you’re checking your phone for those cute face shots!

“How do you handle medical emergencies or medications?”

If your pet takes daily supplements or prescription meds, your sitter needs to be 100% comfortable with the delivery method—whether it’s a pill hidden in a treat or a topical ointment. Ask for their specific protocol if a pet stops eating or shows signs of distress.

How to Find a Trusted Pet Sitter Near You

Finding “the one” takes a little bit of digging, but it’s worth the effort for your pet’s happiness.

Wellbeing From the Inside Out

What you feed your pet is just as vital as who watches them. While you’re away, keeping their nutrition consistent is the best way to prevent stress-related tummy issues. At Wellness Pet, we craft premium recipes with high-quality proteins to ensure your pet stays energized and happy—even when they’re missing you.

Pro-Tip for Pet Parents: Leave a “Pet Care Cheat Sheet” on the counter. Include your vet’s info, your pet’s favorite Wellness(R) Reward+ treats, and a note about their favorite scratching spot!

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I find a pet sitter for a dog with anxiety?

Look for a sitter who specializes in “fear-free” handling and ask for references from other owners of anxious pets. A professional will know how to use low-energy body language to build trust.

What is the difference between a pet sitter and a dog walker?

A dog walker typically provides exercise during the day, while a pet sitter provides more comprehensive care, often including feedings, evening let-outs, or overnight stays in your home.

Should I leave the TV on for my pet while I’m away?

Yes! Background noise can help mask outside sounds that might startle a pet and provides a sense of “company” in a quiet house.

At Wellness Pet, we’re obsessed with the wellbeing of your furry family. By choosing the right sitter and the right nutrition, you’re making sure your pet thrives every single day—no matter where you are. 

Join the Wellness community today to get this guide plus expert nutrition tips and exclusive savings delivered straight to your inbox!